Mindy Kaling and I still have plenty in common, especially our hatred of skiing. But somewhere between the Chanel sales and elite preschools, I started wondering if my imaginary best friend and I are drifting apart.
Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars
I have spent years believing that Mindy Kaling and I could probably be friends.
Not best friends, necessarily. I understand she has people. But the kind of friends who sit on a couch, complain about exercise, order something delicious, and agree that going out sounded much more appealing three hours ago.
So much about Kaling has always felt familiar to me. Her complicated feelings about her body. Her desire to stay home and watch a good movie instead of going to a club.
In her new collection of six essays, I Did Everything Right, Right?, I still found plenty of moments where I thought, yes, exactly. But something else was happening this time around.
The more famous Mindy Kaling gets, the less I can relate to her life.
And unfortunately, relatability has always been a big part of why her essays worked so well for me.
Mindy and Me, Drifting Apart Over Chanel
The collection covers everything from private preschool admissions and aging eyesight to skiing, a stolen car, fashion, and the apparently heart-stopping excitement of learning that Chanel is having a sale.
And listen, I understand the Chanel excitement in theory.
I would also like Chanel.
I would actually like quite a lot of Chanel.
But there is a difference between fantasizing about expensive things and being able to sprint toward Rodeo Drive because a luxury boutique has suddenly become slightly less financially horrifying.
That gap kept popping up for me throughout the collection.
Kaling writes about being dumped by her stylist, private preschool admissions, high-end shopping, and the kind of life that naturally comes with being an incredibly successful actress, writer, producer, and director. None of that is a criticism of her. She worked for her success. She gets to enjoy it.
Kudos for a life well lived.
But it changes the relationship between writer and reader.
Earlier in Kaling’s career, even when her circumstances were already very different from mine, I could almost always find an emotional doorway into whatever she was writing about. Maybe I didn’t have her job or her bank account, but I understood the insecurity, ambition, awkwardness, family dynamics, dating disasters, fashion anxiety, or desperate desire to belong.
There was always an “Oh my God, me too!” somewhere.
This time, I found myself saying it less often.
Except About Skiing. She Is Completely Right About Skiing.
Thank goodness for “Well, We All Hate Skiing.”
Because, Mindy, I am back.
I also despise skiing.
I want to like skiing. Skiing looks wonderful in movies. Everyone has adorable sweaters. There are fireplaces. There are drinks. Mountains are gorgeous. The whole thing looks like one extended Ralph Lauren advertisement.
Then someone expects me to strap boards to my feet and voluntarily launch myself down a frozen mountain.
Absolutely not.
I love a ski trip. I simply don’t need the skiing portion of it.
This essay is the version of Kaling I connect with most easily: funny, slightly exasperated, observant, and willing to say what plenty of people are probably thinking while everyone else insists they’re having the time of their lives.
The Voice Is Still the Reason to Read
Even when I couldn’t relate to the subject matter, I never stopped enjoying Kaling’s voice.
That’s her superpower.
I read these essays, but I could hear her saying every single sentence in my head.
The timing. The emphasis. The little incredulous pauses. That particular combination of confidence and self-deprecation that has run through so much of her work.
Whether she’s writing an essay or creating a television series, Kaling has an unmistakable point of view, and spending time in that voice is still fun.
There’s also something interesting about reading her thoughts at this stage in her life.
The central question running underneath these essays feels like the one in the title: what happens when you did all the things you were supposed to do, worked ridiculously hard, became wildly successful, built the life you wanted… and you’re still wondering whether you’re doing any of it correctly?
That part is relatable no matter what your preschool tuition looks like.
Success apparently does not come with the secret instruction manual the rest of us assume successful people received in the mail.
Which is both reassuring and mildly disappointing.
Final Thoughts
I liked I Did Everything Right, Right?, and I genuinely loved some essays. There were also moments when I felt a little farther away from Kaling than I used to.
Maybe that’s inevitable. People change. Their lives change. Writers who once felt like they were standing next to you eventually start writing from wherever life has taken them.
I’d rather she write honestly about the strange, privileged, complicated life she actually has than manufacture relatability for people like me. But I can still miss that old feeling of turning the page and discovering one more ridiculous thing we had in common.
If you’re already a fan of Kaling’s voice, I’d recommend it. Her humor, observations, insecurities, and ability to make her internal monologue entertaining are all still here. Just know that depending on your life, you may spend a little less time saying, “Me too!” and a little more time thinking, “I have absolutely no idea what it’s like to shop a Chanel sale.”
I Did Everything Right, Right? will hit Amazon on January 12, 2027: Pre-Order Now!
Thank you to NetGalley and Amazon Original Stories for the advanced reader’s copy. All opinions are my own.


![Everyone Who Can Forgive Me is Dead by Jenny Hollander [Book Review] Everyone Who Can Forgive Me is Dead by Jenny Hollander [Book Review]](https://mpd-biblio-covers.imgix.net/9781250890856.jpg)

![Such a Clever Girl by Darby Kane [Book Review] Such a Clever Girl by Darby Kane [Book Review]](https://ashbydodd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/such-a-clever-girl-hero-370x300.png)
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(748x106:750x108)/Questlove-to-Pen-New-Book-on-History-of-Hip-Hop-022124-2-413fed9e46374107a754217dd18ba461.jpg)