Lyda Trueblood’s husbands had a bad habit of dying, and Gregg and Morgan Olsen did serious homework to piece the case together. The research is impressive, though I didn’t always feel pulled into the story.
Rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars
There’s something especially unsettling about a murder story built around someone who seemed so ordinary. No secret lair or criminal operation, just marriages, insurance policies, and a number of dead husbands.
Ordinary Wife by Gregg Olsen and Morgan Olsen digs into the story of Lyda Trueblood, an Idaho woman whose husbands had a troubling habit of dying after she married them. Add in the deaths of her brother-in-law and her two-year-old daughter, and “troubling habit” starts to feel like an understatement.
I listened to the audiobook, narrated by Karen Peakes, and admired the research a lot more than I got swept up in the story.
A Very Suspicious Pattern
In August 1920, Lyda’s new husband, Ed Meyer, became gravely ill after a visit to Blue Lakes Ranch in Idaho. He died in early September, and he wasn’t the first husband to die after marrying her. Over about five years, Lyda married multiple men who died under suspicious circumstances, many of them linked to arsenic poisoning. There were insurance policies, mounting suspicions, and eventually a 1921 trial for Meyer’s murder that turned her into a national sensation.
It’s the kind of case that sounds almost too tidy when you reduce it to a sentence: woman marries men, men die, woman profits. The actual story is considerably messier.
The Research Is the Real Strength
The amount of research behind Ordinary Wife deserves a lot of credit. Gregg and Morgan Olsen drew on court transcripts, prison records, and Lyda’s own statements, and there’s a big difference between saying “wow, an unusual number of husbands died around this woman” and actually reconstructing the marriages, deaths, investigations, money, and legal proceedings. This book does the latter. That level of detail gives the story weight, especially since so much of Lyda’s case comes from a time when recordkeeping and forensic science worked very differently than they do now.
The story also doesn’t stop when the trial ends. Lyda goes to prison, and then she escapes, because apparently several dead husbands and a sensational murder trial weren’t enough drama for one lifetime. I appreciated that the authors kept following her past the courtroom. It gave the book something beyond the familiar true-crime structure of suspicious deaths, arrest, trial, verdict, goodbye.
So Much Detail, Still So Many Questions
The homework does show sometimes. There are a lot of details and timelines to keep straight, and occasionally, it felt like I was being briefed on the case instead of pulled into it.
Even with all that detail, something unknowable still sits at the center of Lyda’s story. Newspaper coverage can tell you what people believed, court records can tell you what prosecutors argued, and witness accounts can tell you what someone remembered, but none of them necessarily give you the whole truth. I came away wondering what else was going on beyond the insurance money, how much of what was said about her got distorted because she was already a national sensation, and what really happened in every death connected to her.
The Danger of Looking Ordinary
It’s almost embarrassingly easy to assume danger will announce itself. Surely someone capable of terrible things will look suspicious, and surely someone will notice. Except sometimes the person looks like a charming new wife who cooks dinner.
Ordinary Wife works best when it pushes against that assumption. Lyda reportedly knew how to come across as appealing, respectable, and trustworthy, and men kept marrying her. Then the people around her kept dying. Marriage gave her closeness, trust, and a spot as the beneficiary on the insurance policies, which is far more disturbing than any theatrical villain could be.
![Ordinary Wife by Gregg Olsen and Morgan Olsen [Audiobook Review]](http://ashbydodd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Extraordinary-Ordinary-Wife-Review-768x1024.png)
Karen Peakes Keeps the Narration Grounded
Karen Peakes was a good fit for this audiobook. She doesn’t overplay the shocking parts, which I appreciated, because this story really doesn’t need more drama. Her narration stays steady, letting the weirdness of Lyda’s life settle in naturally.
Final Thoughts
Ordinary Wife is a thoroughly researched look at a fascinating historical true-crime case, and the post-trial material gives it more depth than I expected. The sheer amount of detail occasionally gets in the way of the storytelling, so readers who want true crime to be immersive and highly narrative may find parts of it a little dry. But if you like historical crime, there’s plenty here to keep you interested.
Thank you to NetGalley and Storm Publishing for the advanced reader’s copy. All opinions are my own.




![Next Time Will Be Our Turn by Jesse Q. Sutanto [Book Review] Next Time Will Be Our Turn by Jesse Q. Sutanto [Book Review]](https://ashbydodd.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/06/Next-Time-Will-Be-Our-Turn-hero-370x300.png)

